AmongReaders.com
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

To Win Her Heart

Karen Witemeyer · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Daughter of Joy

Kathleen Morgan · 406 pages

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
❤️

Rekindled

Tamera Alexander

"Left for dead, Larson Jennings, returns home badly burned. His obviously pregnant wife Kathryn is losing their ranch. Disfigured beyond recognition to most--Larson is determined to save his family"--Provided by publisher.

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionCowboys
❤️

Redeeming Love

Francine Rivers · 473 pages

California’s gold country, 1850. A time when men sold their souls for a bag of gold and women sold their bodies for a place to sleep. Angel expects nothing from men but betrayal. Sold into prostitution as a child, she survives by keeping her hatred alive. And what she hates most are the men who use her, leaving her empty and dead inside. Then she meets Michael Hosea. A man who seeks his Father’s

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
❤️
Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
❤️

Pearl in the Sand

Tessa Afshar

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
❤️

Wonderland Creek

Lynn Austin

LibrariansChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
❤️

The Well

Stephanie Landsem · 306 pages

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
❤️

To Love Anew

Bonnie Leon · 304 pages

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical FictionRomance
🙂

At the Scent of Water

Linda Nichols

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Levi's Will

W. Dale Cramer · 397 pages

"A family saga of pain and reconciliation set behind the closed doors of an Amish community. Spanning three generations, the story follows the life of Will McGruder, who having fled as a young man, seeks to heal the past by bringing his new family to meet his Amish relatives"--Provided by publisher.

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical Fiction
🙂

Remember

Karen Kingsbury, Gary Smalley · 515 pages

Convinced she could make it on her own, Ashley Baxter has kept the most important people in her life at a distance--her family, the man who loves her, and the God she is sure can never forgive her. Now, just as she begins to open her heart, the events of September 11 rip into Ashley's world and she is led to heartbreaking and hope-filled decisions that will forever change her life.

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂
Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

You're the One that I Want

Susan May Warren

"Owen Christiansen has been in a downward spiral since an injury ended his NHL career. But a job on an Alaskan crabbing boat offers a fresh start . . . maybe even a shot at romance with Elise "Scotty" McFlynn, the captain's daughter"--

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Romancing Olive

Holly Bush · 285 pages

In 1891, spinster librarian, Olive Wilkins, is shocked to learn of her brother’s violent death at a saloon gaming table and her sister-in-law’s subsequent murder, traveling far from her staid life to rescue her niece and nephew, now orphans. She arrives to find the circumstances of her brother’s life deplorable and her long held beliefs of family and tradition, shaken. Accustomed to the sophis

LibrariansHistorical FictionRomanceCowboys
🙂

The Broken Road

Richard Paul Evans · 338 pages

Chicago celebrity Charles James can't shake the nightmare that wakes him each night. He sees himself walking down a long, broken highway the sides of which are lit in flames. Where is he going? Why is he walking? What is the wailing he hears around him? By day, he wonders why he's so haunted and unhappy when he has all he ever wanted -- fame, fans, and fortune and the lavish lifestyle it affor

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Sweetwater Gap

Denise Hunter · 320 pages

When Josephine's family insists she come home to help with the harvest, the timing works. But her return isn't simple benevolence-she plans to persuade the family to sell the failing orchard. The new manager's presence is making it difficult. Grady MacKenzie takes an immediate disliking to Josephine and becomes outright cantankerous when she tries talking her family into selling. As she and Gra

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Long Way Gone

Charles Martin · 320 pages

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Amish Widow's Hope

Samantha Price · 208 pages

Newly widowed Amish woman, Anita Graber, has returned to live with her brother and his family in Lancaster County. As an expectant widow, she is quite surprised when everyone from the bishop's wife to her brother decides that her baby needs a father. Anita endures many embarrassing moments as she's forced into one awkward situation after another. Even though another man is the last thing on her mi

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Trapped

Irene Hannon · 396 pages

LibrariansChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Chateau of Echoes

Siri L. Mitchell, Siri Mitchell

Suddenly widowed in a foreign country, Frédérique Farmer did what any girl would do: She bought a castle. She just never imagined that its mysterious fifteenth-century owner would hold the keys to her second chance at life. When an extensive restoration of the chateau reveals an ancient treasure, Frédérique kisses her reclusive life good-bye. She opens a bed-and-breakfast, hires a capricious g

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

Just Beyond the Clouds

Karen Kingsbury · 335 pages

#1 bestselling author Karen Kingsbury tells the heartwrenching story of Cody Gunner, a widower fighting for stability, and the woman who wants to help him trust again--even when trust is the most terrifying thing of all.Still aching over his wife's death, Cody Gunner can't bear the thought of also letting go of his Down's Syndrome brother, Carl Joseph. Cody wants his brother home, where he will be

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
🙂

The Rosemary Tree

Elizabeth Goudge · 320 pages

Michael Stone was once a famous author. That was before he went to prison. Now, just released, he needs to get his bearings and a new beginning. It was a gray day in early April when Michael stumbled wearily into the tiny English village. Weighed down by failure and despair, the town of Silverbridge seems too offer him a quiet, rural escape from the past. Even though his heart was torn by remorse

Second ChancesChristian FictionHistorical Fiction
🙂

The River Is Waiting

Wally Lamb · 451 pages

Corby Ledbetter is struggling. New fatherhood, the loss of his job, and a growing secret addiction have thrown his marriage to his beloved Emily into a tailspin. And that's before he causes the tragedy that tears the family apart. Sentenced to prison, Corby struggles to survive life on the inside, where he bears witness to frightful acts of brutality but also experiences small acts of kindness

Second ChancesLibrarians
🙂

Goodbyes and Second Chances

T.I. Lowe · 314 pages

Second ChancesChristian FictionRomance
📖 New 2026 Kindles just released. See them on Amazon ↗