AmongReaders.com
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Darkness Falls

Cate Tiernan · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Bewitching

Alex Flinn

Tells the story of Kendra, a witch, and the first three-hundred years of her life, including takes on a classic fairy tale, the 1666 plague in Britain, the Titanic disaster, and the story of a modern-day, plain stepsister.

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFantasy
❤️

The Witch's Daughter

Paula Brackston · 432 pages

Witnessing the death of her witch mother in the spring of 1628, Bess Hawksmith turns to secluded warlock Gideon Masters for protection and learns formidable powers, including immortality, skills she begins teaching to a new apprentice centuries later.

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

The Indigo Spell

Richelle Mead

In the aftermath of a forbidden moment that rocked Sydney to her core, she finds herself struggling to draw the line between her Alchemist teachings and what her heart is urging her to do. Then she meets alluring, rebellious Marcus Finch—a former Alchemist who escaped against all odds, and is now on the run. Marcus wants to teach Sydney the secrets he claims the Alchemists are hiding from her. But

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person Narrator
❤️

Circe

Madeline Miller · 408 pages

In the house of Helios, god of the sun and mightiest of the Titans, a daughter is born. But Circe is a strange child—not powerful, like her father, nor viciously alluring like her mother. Turning to the world of mortals for companionship, she discovers that she does possess power—the power of witchcraft, which can transform rivals into monsters and menace the gods themselves. Threatened, Zeus b

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

In the Forests of the Night

Amelia Atwater-Rhodes · 147 pages

I was born to the name of Rachel Weatere in the year 1684, more than three hundred years ago.The one who changed me named me Risika, and Risika I became, though I never asked what it meant. I continue to call myself Risika, even though I was transformed into what I am against my will.By day, Risika sleeps in a shaded room in Concord, Massachusetts. By night, she hunts the streets of New York Cit

ImmortalityYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Shadowland

Alyson Noel · 368 pages

ImmortalityYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

The Goddess Test

Aimee Carter · 298 pages

Eden, Michigan, high school student Kate Winters strikes a bargain with Henry, Greek god of the underworld, if he'll cure her dying mother of cancer. The bargain she strikes with him is a grim one, but the full enormity of what she has undertaken--"live forever or die trying"--is not revealed until it's too late to recant.

ImmortalityYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Black Blood

Christopher Pike · 196 pages

Surviving through countless centuries, Alisa is beautiful, strong and deadly. Alisa has long been hiding a dark and deadly secret, but it seems that someone is finally onto her. When a private investigator is hired to delve into Alisa's personal affairs, her shocking true age and untraceable fortune are uncovered.

ImmortalityYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Night World, No. 1

L.J. Smith

Witches & WitchcraftImmortalityYoung AdultFantasy
❤️

Mortal Danger

Ann Aguirre · 388 pages

Agreeing to join the mysterious Kian's magical faction to exact revenge on a group of bullies who have tormented her, Edie transforms into a beautiful girl and begins to sabotage the bullies' inner circle only to discover dark truths about Kian's world. Edie is being bullied, and she's come to the end of her rope, until mysterious Kian shows up to make her dreams come true if she signs an agreeme

ImmortalityYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️
ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFantasy
❤️

Hexbound

Chloe Neill

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Tiger's Destiny

Colleen Houck · 455 pages

Kelsey, Ren, and Kishan race against time and the evil sorcerer Lokesh on the Andaman Islands in the Bay of Bengal as they seek Durga's final gift, the Rope of Fire, that will finally break the tiger's curse.

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFantasy
❤️

Tempt Me with Darkness

Shayla Black · 440 pages

He's an immortal knight hungering for satisfaction.... As soon as Marrok sees Olivia Gray's dark windswept hair and burning violet eyes, he's sure they've met in eons past. He's felt her soft gentle curves writhing in pleasure beneath his own hard powerful body...Morganna! For centuries, towering Marrok, once the mightiest of King Arthur's warriors, has endured a terrible curse cast upon him w

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftFantasyFemale Lead
❤️

The Witch Hunter

Virginia Boecker · 384 pages

Sentenced to death after being wrongly accused of engaging in witchcraft, former witch hunter Elizabeth Grey receives unexpected assistance from a former enemy, a wizard who offers to save her life if she will break a deadly curse.

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

The Near Witch

Victoria Schwab · 337 pages

The Near Witch is only an old story told to frighten children. If the wind calls at night, you must not listen. The wind is lonely, and always looking for company. There are no strangers in the town of Near. These are the truths that Lexi has heard all her life. But when an actual stranger, a boy who seems to fade like smoke, appears outside her home on the moor at night, she knows tha

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Texas Gothic

Rosemary Clement-Moore · 416 pages

Amy Goodnight's family is far from normal. She comes from a line of witches, but tries her best to stay far outside the family business. Her summer gig? Ranch-sitting for her aunt with her wacky but beautiful sister. Only the Goodnight Ranch is even less normal than it normally is. Bodies are being discovered, a ghost is on the prowl, and everywhere she turns, the hot neighbor cowboy is in her fac

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Inner Demons

Sarra Cannon · 204 pages

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

A Nameless Witch

A. Lee Martinez · 330 pages

Hiding her inherent beauty while hunting for men to consume, an immortal witch enters a reluctant partnership with the pure-hearted White Knight in order to counter the efforts of an insane sorcerer who is threatening their world.

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

The Short Second Life of Bree Tanner

Stephenie Meyer · 192 pages

This novella tells the story of Bree Tanner, a character first introduced in Eclipse, and the darker side of the newborn vampire world she inhabits. In another irresistible combination of danger, mystery, and romance, Stephenie Meyer tells the devastating story of Bree and the newborn army as they prepare to close in on Bella Swan and the Cullens, following their encounter to its unforgettable con

ImmortalityYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Once a Witch

Carolyn MacCullough · 309 pages

Born into a family of witches, seventeen-year-old Tamsin is raised believing that she alone lacks a magical "Talent," but when her beautiful and powerful sister is taken by an age-old rival of the family in an attempt to change the balance of power, Tamsin discovers her true destiny.

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Wings of Wrath

C.S. Friedman · 406 pages

In a cloak-and-dagger world of survival, Kamela, witch turned immortal Magister, flees north in a desperate attempt to uncover the truth about how the mysterious Souleaters were once defeated--a truth that paves the way to war.

ImmortalityWitches & WitchcraftFantasyFemale Lead
❤️

Petty Magic: Being the Memoirs and Confessions of Miss Evelyn Harbinger, Temptress and Troublemaker

Camille DeAngelis · 296 pages

Using witchcraft to extend her considerable life, Evelyn Harbinger dons a youthful appearance to catch the eye of a man she believes to be the reincarnation of a beloved World War II espionage partner who lost his life helping her to advance the Allied cause.

Witches & WitchcraftImmortalityFirst Person NarratorFantasy
❤️

Sisters' Fate

Jessica Spotswood · 364 pages

"In the final book in the Cahill Witch Chronicles, the Sisters' and the Brotherhood near all-out war as an epidemic breaks out in New London, and the prophecy that one sister will murder another comes ever closer to fruition"--

Witches & WitchcraftYoung AdultFantasyFirst Person Narrator
📖 New 2026 Kindles just released. See them on Amazon ↗