Books like…
Loved Murder at the Vicarage by Agatha Christie? If its mystery, classics and series hooked you, these 20 books hit the same notes — starting with Still Life, Murder at Holly House and How to Solve Your Own Murder. Every pick is matched by what’s actually inside the book, not just its genre, and we skip other books by the same author so you find someone new.
What’s inside Murder at the Vicarage: Mystery · Classics · Series · Cozy Mystery · Detective Fiction
Louise Penny
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Detective Fiction · Cozy Mystery · Cozy
Denzil Meyrick
Red Herrings · Closed Circle of Suspects · Detective Fiction · Small Town Secrets · Dry Humor
Kristen Perrin
Red Herrings · Closed Circle of Suspects · Small Town Secrets · Cozy · Cozy Mystery
Elizabeth Peters
Red Herrings · Closed Circle of Suspects · Cozy · Cozy Mystery · Detective Fiction
Richard Coles
Closed Circle of Suspects · Cozy Mystery · Small Town Secrets · Dry Humor · Charming
Alan Bradley
Red Herrings · Cozy Mystery · Detective Fiction · Cozy · Dry Humor
Jess Kidd
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Cozy Mystery · Elderly Protagonist · Dry Humor
Richard Osman
Red Herrings · Cozy Mystery · Dry Humor · Elderly Protagonist · Charming
Carolyn Keene
Red Herrings · Detective Fiction · Cozy · Whodunit · Charming
Clare Mackintosh
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Detective Fiction · Small Town Secrets · Whodunit
Gladys Mitchell
Small Town Secrets · Detective Fiction · Elderly Protagonist · Dry Humor · Whodunit
Jesse Q. Sutanto
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Cozy Mystery · Whodunit · Cozy
J.K. Rowling
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Detective Fiction · Dry Humor · Whodunit
P.D. James
Closed Circle of Suspects · Detective Fiction · Small Town Secrets · Whodunit · Cozy Mystery
Claudia Gray
Red Herrings · Closed Circle of Suspects · Cozy Mystery · Cozy · Charming
Raymond Chandler
Detective Fiction · Red Herrings · Dry Humor · Classics · Mystery
Charlaine Harris
Closed Circle of Suspects · Cozy Mystery · Whodunit · Dry Humor · Mystery
Sue Grafton
Red Herrings · Detective Fiction · Dry Humor · Small Town Secrets · Whodunit
Julia Seales
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Cozy · Cozy Mystery · Charming
Kate Khavari
Closed Circle of Suspects · Red Herrings · Cozy · Whodunit · Charming
More “books like” lists
Books like The Eternity Code Books like Days of Blood & Starlight Books like The Alienist Books like His Dark Materials Books like My Ántonia Books like Anne of the Island Books like Milk and Honey Books like The Couple Next Door