AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

In the Shadow of Gotham

Stefanie Pintoff · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Hide books by the same author
❤️

The Angel of Darkness

Caleb Carr · 648 pages

In one of the most critically acclaimed novels of the year, Caleb Carr-- bestselling author of The Alienist--pits Dr. Laszlo Kreizler and his colleagues against a murderer as evil as the darkest night. . . .From the Paperback edition.

Historical MysteryCriminal ProfilingNew York CityMystery
❤️

A Front Page Affair

Radha Vatsal

New York City, 1915. Intelligent, well-traveled, and well-bred, Capability "Kitty" Weeks never expected to find herself reporting on fashion trends and society gossip, but every aspiring journalist has to start somewhere, and Kitty finds her "in" to the world of newspapers on the New York Sentinel Ladies' Page. Meanwhile, news headlines buzz about a shooting at J.P. Morgan's mansion and the sinkin

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Murder on Astor Place

Victoria Thompson · 278 pages

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Deadly Affection

Cuyler Overholt · 454 pages

"One of the first women practicing in the advanced new field of psychology, Dr. Genevieve Summerford is used to forging her own path. But when one of her patients is arrested for murder--a murder Genevieve fears she may have unwittingly provoked--she is forced to seek help to solve the crime and clear her patient's name ... and her own"--

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Murder Your Darlings

J.J. Murphy · 316 pages

When she stumbles over the dead body of drama critic Leland Mayflower and an aspiring writer named Billy Faulkner is accused of the murder, Dorothy Parker investigates with the aid of her fellow Algonquin Round Tablemates.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Seven for a Secret

Lyndsay Faye · 470 pages

Timothy and Valentine Wilde must once again delve into the darkest underbelly of old New York. When the beautiful and terrified Mrs Lucy Adams stumbles into the Tombs, headquarters of New York's newly formed police force, it's the beginning of a dense, thorny maze of crime for copper star Timothy Wilde. He's hardened to the injustices of life in the unforgiving city he's grown up in, but that does

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

The Queen of Bedlam

Robert McCammon · 656 pages

Investigating New York City's first serial killer in 1702, magistrate's clerk Matthew Corbert contemplates working with an elderly asylum resident who may hold the key to the killer's identity, in a case that is further challenged by the murderer's dark designs for the city.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Curtain Falls

Stefanie Pintoff · 403 pages

1906. When a chorus girl is found dead on a Broadway stage, dressed in the leading lady's costume, Mulvaney knows that news of a possible serial killer would be potentially disastrous to the burgeoning theater world.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Plague on Both Your Houses

Susanna Gregory · 406 pages

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️
Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Heiress of Linn Hagh

Karen Charlton · 325 pages

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Bookseller's Tale

Ann Swinfen · 258 pages

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

Roman Blood

Steven Saylor · 384 pages

80 BC: Gordianus accepts a commission from Cicero to investigate a murder while Rome is under the thumb of a brutal dictator. The client is Sextus Roscius, who was accused of parricide. The novel is derived from Cicero's Murder Trials and features Marcus Tullius Tiro among others.

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

Claws of the Cat

Susan Spann · 326 pages

In sixteenth-century Japan, master ninja Hiro and the Jesuit priest he is sworn to protect race against time to prevent a wrongful execution by solving the murder of a samurai whose death is linked to numerous possible suspects.

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Mask of Ra

Paul Doherty · 384 pages

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

Heresy

S.J. Parris · 435 pages

"Giordano Bruno was a monk, poet, scientist, and magician on the run from the Roman Inquisition on charges of heresy for his belief that the Earth orbits the sun and that the universe is infinite. This alone could have got him burned at the stake, but he was also a student of occult philosophies and magic. In S. J. Parris's gripping novel, Bruno's pursuit of this rare knowledge brings him to Londo

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Queen's Man

Sharon Kay Penman · 291 pages

The 12th Century sleuth, Justin de Quincy, investigates a murder which could shed light on a plot to usurp the crown of England. Prince John is scheming to unseat his brother, King Richard the Lionheart, who went missing as he was returning from a crusade.

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

Jade Dragon Mountain

Elsa Hart · 423 pages

"On the mountainous border of China and Tibet in 1708, a detective must learn what a killer already knows: that empires rise and fall on the strength of the stories they tell. Li Du is an imperial librarian in exile. Arriving in Dayan, the last Chinese town before the Tibetan border, he is surprised to find it teeming with travelers, soldiers, and merchants, all come for the spectacle of an eclips

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

A Dark Anatomy

Robin Blake · 359 pages

Lancashire, England, 1740. A grim discovery has been made: a squire's wife, Dolores Brockletower, lies in the woods above her home at Garlick Hall, her throat brutally slashed. Called to the scene, Coroner Titus Cragg finds the Brockletower household awash with rumor and suspicion. He enlists the help of his astute young friend, doctor Luke Fidelis, to throw light on the case.

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Ashes of London

Andrew Taylor · 496 pages

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

Billy Boyle

James R. Benn · 304 pages

Billy Boyle, a young Irish-American cop from Boston, has just made detective when World War II breaks out. His "Uncle Ike" is Dwight D. Eisenhower, plucked from obscurity to command Army forces in Europe, and he wants Billy to be his personal investigator. Accompanied by an aristocratic Polish officer in exile and a beautiful British WREN, his mission is to catch a spy who may have been planted in

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Chatelet Apprentice

Jean-Francois Parot · 343 pages

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

The Dragon Scroll

I.J. Parker · 338 pages

Introducing Sugawara Akitada—the hero of a riveting mystery series that captures the rich and exotic culture of ancient JapanIn an adventure filled with highway bandits, unscrupulous politicians, and renegade monks, The Dragon Scroll introduces readers to the lively world of eleventh-century Japan and an irrepressible hero—Sugawara Akitada. On his first official assignment, Akitada—an impoverished

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries Starter
🙂

Oh Danny Boy

Rhys Bowen · 352 pages

Irish immigrant-turned-private detective Molly Murphy comes to the aid of handsome NYPD captain Daniel Sullivan, who has been arrested for accepting bribes, in a mystery set in early twentieth-century New York.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.