AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

The Captive Heart

Dale Cramer · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

The Believer

Ann H. Gabhart

Elizabeth Duncan has nowhere to turn. In charge of her younger brother and sister after their parents die, her options are limited. When she hears that the Shaker community in the next county takes in orphans, she presents herself and her siblings at Harmony Hill. Despite the hard work and strange new beliefs around her, Elizabeth is relieved to have a roof overhead and food to eat. But when she f

Christian FictionReligious IdentityForbidden LoveHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Voice in the Wind

Francine Rivers · 515 pages

Following the prides and passions of a group of Jews, Romans and Barbarians living at the time of the siege, the narrative is centered on an ill-fated romance between a steadfast slave girl, Hadassah, and Marcus, the brother of her owner and a handsome aristocrat. After surviving the massacre of her family and the destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans, Hadassah is captured and sold to a well-to-d

Christian FictionForbidden LoveReligious IdentityHistorical Fiction
❤️

The Longing

Beverly Lewis · 467 pages

**A single moment can transform a life... and a heart** Although she still thinks of Caleb Yoder, Nellie Mae Fisher has broken up with her beau, choosing instead to follow the ways of the New Order. Yet her yearning for a husband remains, and new possibilities beckon, taking her heart by surprise. A tragic accident binds Caleb once more to the father who so opposed his affection for Nellie..

Christian FictionForbidden LoveReligious IdentityHistorical Fiction
❤️

The Hidden Flame

Davis Bunn, Janette Oke · 400 pages

In first-century Judea, the followers of the Way have burgeoned into a vibrant, growing community that cannot be ignored. Jerusalem is in turmoil as its religious leaders on one side, and their Roman rulers on the other, conspire to stamp out the fledgling Church. And Abigail, who thought she had finally found home and safety, is caught between the opposing forces.Two suitors desire the lovely Abi

Christian FictionForbidden LoveReligious IdentityHistorical Fiction
❤️

Then Came Heaven

LaVyrle Spencer · 368 pages

Can love survive a shattering loss? Browerville, Minnesota, 1950: Life is just about perfect for Eddie Olczak. A man of unshakable faith, he derives intense pleasure from the life he's built. He cherishes his wife, Krystyna, their daughters, Anne and Lucy, and his job as handyman for St. Joseph's, the Catholic church that is the cornerstone of Browerville life. But when a tragic accident cuts

Christian FictionForbidden LoveReligious IdentityHistorical Fiction
❤️

Plain Perfect

Beth Wiseman · 305 pages

"A search for peace in Amish country proves anything but simple for a woman on the run from life...and herself. On the rolling plains of Lancaster County, PA., Lillian Miller is searching for her grandparents' house...and so much more. After years of neglect and abuse, she's turning to a lifestyle of simplicity among the Amish to find herself. As she discards the distractions of her former life, s

Christian FictionForbidden LoveReligious IdentitySeries
❤️

A Daughter's Inheritance

Tracie Peterson, Judith McCoy Miller · 383 pages

Seventeen-year-old Fanny has never put much stock in the conventions of society. In fact, she has given her heart to Michael, the family boat-keeper. But when she receives a surprising inheritance, she discovers just how oppressive society can be . . . and that she may be trusting the wrong people. Dare she follow her heart and risk going against her family? What if she loses everything she's e

Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
❤️

The Miner's Lady

Tracie Peterson

Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Abinadi

H.B. Moore · 260 pages

When King Noah demands that Raquel, a daughter of one of his priests, join his harem, she flees the only life she has ever known and marries her secret love, Abinadi. They live happily together in their community of believers, enjoying their firstborn son, until the Lord calls Abinadi as His prophet with a mission that will test the couple's faith--even unto death.

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Somewhere to Belong

Judith McCoy Miller · 567 pages

Although she's always longed to see the outside world, Johanna Ilg believes her future is rooted in the Amana community inhabited by devout Christians. But when she learns a troubling secret, the world she thought she knew is shattered and she is forced to make difficult choices about a new life and the man she left behind. Berta Schumacher has lived a privileged life in Chicago, and when her pare

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Wings of the Morning

Lori Wick · 273 pages

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

The Waiting

Suzanne Woods Fisher

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Counted With the Stars

Connilyn Cossette · 352 pages

Sold into slavery by her father and forsaken by the man she was supposed to marry, young Egyptian Kiya must serve a mistress who takes pleasure in her humiliation. When terrifying plagues strike Egypt, Kiya is in the middle of it all. Choosing to flee with the Hebrews, Kiya finds herself reliant on a strange God and drawn to a man who despises her people. With everything she's ever known swept

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionRomance
🙂

The Well

Stephanie Landsem · 306 pages

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

The Gates of Zion

Bodie Thoene, Brock Thoene · 382 pages

Historical Fiction based on fact. Time-frame is the end of WW II just before the establishment of Israel as a country.

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
🙂
Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Love's Awakening

Laura Frantz · 493 pages

Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

The Amish Bride

Mindy Starns Clark, Leslie Gould

Christian FictionReligious IdentityForbidden LoveRomance
🙂

An Amish Buggy Ride

Sarah Price · 220 pages

Quiet and soft-spoken, Kate Zook is the responsible eldest daughter in an Amish family and prides herself on fulfilling her role. Then, one fateful snowy night, she uncharacteristically speaks her mind--and unwittingly plays a part in a horrible accident. Afterwords, Kate's parents and brother become emotionally withdrawn, and Kate is unable to forgive herself. Someone outside the home takes an in

Christian FictionReligious IdentityForbidden LoveRomance
🙂

How Do I Love Thee?

Nancy Moser · 322 pages

Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Surrender the Night

MaryLu Tyndall · 318 pages

"When British soldiers invade Baltimore amid the War of 1812, Rose McGuire, alone on her family farm, is easy prey for a brutal lieutenant. In the midst of the attack, she's saved by British 2nd Lieutenant Alexander Reed. Will she now have to heal, as well as hide, this wounded enemy soldier..."--P. [4] of cover.

Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

A Love Forbidden

Kathleen Morgan

Christian FictionForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

Lady of Avalon

Marion Zimmer Bradley, Diana L. Paxson · 480 pages

New York Times bestselling author Marion Zimmer Bradley brings the mesmerizing world of myth, romance and history to life in the spellbinding novel of epic grandeur!Before the legend of King Arthur and Camelot, there was Avalon, a beautiful island of golden vales and silver mists. A land where the lives of three powerful priestesses shape the destiny of Roman Britian as they fight to regain the ma

Religious IdentityForbidden LoveHistorical FictionSeries
🙂

The Sister Wife

Diane Noble

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.