AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Blue Moon

Wendy Corsi Staub · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Haven

Kay Hooper · 326 pages

After a head injury brings on nightmares involving girls being tortured and murdered, Emma Rayburn contacts her estranged sister, Jessie, a psychic investigator. Another nightmare, in the woods this time. Different: she was running. Trying to escape. But the same ending: another dead girl... Jessie, psychic investigator for a firm called Haven, has been estranged from her sister Emma for years. N

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Guess Again

Charlie Donlea · 352 pages

Behind bars, a killer holds the key. Outside, an obsession turns deadly in this masterfully twisty new thriller from the bestselling author of Twenty Years Later.Silence of the Lambs meets Cruel Summer in GUESS AGAIN, as #1 internationally bestselling author Charlie Donlea dives into the long shadow of trauma on a small town, hybristophilia and the allure of evil, and the toll the truth can take o

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Faithless

Karin Slaughter · 537 pages

"Brilliant plotting, relentless suspense," raved the Washington Post. "A new synonym for terror," crowned the Detroit Free Press. The critics agree: no one writes suspense like Karin Slaughter, whose thrillers featuring medical examiner Sara Linton and her ex-husband, police chief Jeffrey Tolliver, have propelled her to the top of bestseller lists the world over. Now Slaughter fuses her unmatched

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Down the Darkest Road

Tami Hoag · 432 pages

Deeper Than the Dead introduced Tami Hoag's millions of fans to Oak Knoll, a small California town that, in the mid-eighties, seemed as idyllic as any . . . until the See-No-Evil killer shattered that notion. It took FBI agent Vince Leone and a new technique called "profiling" to put an end to the trauma. Secrets to the Grave brought Leone's teacher-turned-child- advocate wife, Anne, into a centra

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

The Last Sister

Kendra Elliot · 328 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Pray for Silence

Linda Castillo · 304 pages

Chief of Police Kate Burkholder must confront a dark evil to solve the mysterious murders of an entire Amish family of seven. Formerly Amish herself, Kate is no stranger to the secrets the Amish keep from the English--and each other--but this crime is horribly out of the ordinary.

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

The Last Juror

John Grisham · 429 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

His & Hers

Alice Feeney · 308 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Wolfhunter River

Rachel Caine · 330 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

A Perfect Evil

Alex Kava · 428 pages

Serial killer Ronald Jeffreys was executed for three murders. Three months after his death, the body of a boy is found, killed in the same style as Jeffreys' victims. Is there a copycat killer on the loose? Or is this the real thing?

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

The Chemistry of Death

Simon Beckett · 374 pages

Three years ago, David Hunter moved to rural Norfolk to escape his life in London, his gritty work in forensics, and a tragedy that nearly destroyed him. Working as a simple country doctor, seeing his lost wife and daughter only in his dreams, David struggles to remain uninvolved when the corpse of a woman is found in the woods, a macabre sign from her killer decorating her body. In one horrifying

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerSeries
❤️

Tell Me

Lisa Jackson · 464 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

When You See Me

Lisa Gardner · 400 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

A Good Girl's Guide to Murder

Holly Jackson · 400 pages

Everyone is talking about A Good Girl's Guide to Murder! With shades of Serial and Making a Murderer this is the story about an investigation turned obsession, full of twists and turns and with an ending you'll never expect. Everyone in Fairview knows the story. Pretty and popular high school senior Andie Bell was murdered by her boyfriend, Sal Singh, who then killed himself. It was all anyo

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerPsychological Thriller
❤️

Dark of the Moon

John Sandford · 392 pages

Virgil Flowers-tall, lean, late thirties, three times divorced, hair way too long for a cop's-had kicked around for a while before joining the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension. First, it was the army and the military police, then the police in St. Paul, and finally Lucas Davenport had brought him into the BCA, promising him, "We'll only give you the hard stuff."He'd been doing the hard st

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

The Preacher

Camilla Lackberg · 419 pages

The discovery of two murder victims who were killed twenty years earlier is complicated by the body of a third, recent victim at the same location, a case that compels detective Patrik Hedstrom to investigate a feuding clan of misfits, religious fanatics, and criminals.

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

The Quiet Game

Greg Iles · 564 pages

Widower Penn Cage returns to his hometown of Natchez, Mississippi, where, finding that his father is being blackmailed, he reopens a notorious murder case that involves powerfully dangerous town forces, the FBI, and his own past.

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Bonfire

Krysten Ritter · 328 pages

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Walking on Her Grave

Melinda Leigh

The electrifying conclusion of the romantic suspense novella series from Melinda Leigh and Kendra Elliot. The sleepy town of Solitude, Oregon, has turned into ground zero for a turf war between the manufacturers and distributors of a lethal new drug. When a teenage witness disappears, social worker Carly Taylor must find him before he’s silenced permanently. Rogue County investigator Seth Ha

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

It's Not Her

Mary Kubica · 320 pages

AN INSTANT NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER AND A GOODREADS TOP THRILLER OF 2026! “A gripping thrill ride.” —Jeneva Rose “Tantalizing, terrifying and all too real.” —Shari Lapena Two families at a secluded lake resort are at the center of a chilling crime in this twisty thriller from the bestselling author of Local Woman Missing A scream shatters the silence… Courtney Gray’s peaceful vacation turns into

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Defending Jacob

William Landay

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Secrets and Lies

Jacqueline Green · 305 pages

"In Echo Bay, Massachusetts, a beach town haunted by misfortune, Tenley Reed, Sydney Morgan, and Emerson Cunningham come together to investigate a murder, while old mysteries resurface and new dares appear"--

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

In the Clearing

Robert Dugoni · 355 pages

"Detective Tracy Crosswhite has a skill, and a soft spot, for tackling unsolved crimes. Having lost her own sister to murder at a young age, Tracy has dedicated her career to bringing justice and closure to the families and friends of victims of crime. So when Jenny, a former police academy classmate and protégé, asks Tracy to help solve a cold case that involves the suspicious suicide of a Native

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery
❤️

Carnal Innocence

Nora Roberts · 512 pages

In the small town of Innocence, Mississippi, days are long, nights are fragrant, and secrets are hard to keep. But when a brutal killer starts claiming the lives of the town's most attractive women, lifelong neighbors are forced to wonder if the culprit is a stranger lurking in the bayou. Or someone right next door. Burned out by a whirlwind career, world famous concert violinist Caroline Waver

Small Town SecretsTense and SuspensefulThrillerMystery

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.