AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Away in a Manger

Rhys Bowen · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

The Angel of Darkness

Caleb Carr · 648 pages

In one of the most critically acclaimed novels of the year, Caleb Carr-- bestselling author of The Alienist--pits Dr. Laszlo Kreizler and his colleagues against a murderer as evil as the darkest night. . . .From the Paperback edition.

Historical MysteryKids in DangerNew York CityMystery
❤️

Jane and the Twelve Days of Christmas

Stephanie Barron · 337 pages

"The twelfth installment in Stephanie Barron's fan-favorite Being a Jane Austen Mystery series. Christmas Eve, 1814: Jane Austen has been invited to spend the holiday with family and friends at The Vyne, the gorgeous ancestral home of the wealthy and politically prominent Chute family. As the year fades and friends begin to gather beneath the mistletoe for the twelve days of Christmas festivities,

Historical MysteryChristmasMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Star of the East

Tasha Alexander

Historical MysteryChristmasMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Grave Matter

Anna Lee Huber · 421 pages

"Scotland, 1830. Following the death of her dear friend, Lady Kiera Darby is in need of a safe haven. Returning to her childhood home, Kiera hopes her beloved brother, Trevor, and the merriment of the Hogmanay Ball will distract her. But when a caretaker is murdered and a grave is disturbed at nearby Dryburgh Abbey, Kiera is once more thrust into the cold grasp of death. While Kiera knows that aid

Historical MysteryChristmasMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Murder in Murray Hill

Victoria Thompson · 296 pages

"When facing injustice, the residents of nineteenth-century New York City's tenements turn to midwife Sarah Brandt and Detective Sergeant Frank Malloy to protect their rights. Now, as the Edgar and Agatha Award-nominated series continues, the two must track down a cruel criminal preying on the hopes and dreams of innocent women A Gaslight Mystery Frank Malloy has never known any life other than th

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️
Historical MysteryKids in DangerMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Twelfth Night

Deanna Raybourn · 400 pages

Historical MysteryChristmasMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

The Queene's Christmas

Karen Harper · 320 pages

Historical MysteryChristmasMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Deadly Promise

Brenda Joyce · 341 pages

Francesca Cahill is an American heiress. She also happens to be a political activist and an amateur sleuth (detective). Francesca finds out that there a girl missing from the streets and she fears that she may have been abducted. Along with finding her, she has also accepted Calder Harts proposal for marriage which puts her on the outs with Rick, the police commissioner and Harts brother. Howeve

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Front Page Affair

Radha Vatsal

New York City, 1915. Intelligent, well-traveled, and well-bred, Capability "Kitty" Weeks never expected to find herself reporting on fashion trends and society gossip, but every aspiring journalist has to start somewhere, and Kitty finds her "in" to the world of newspapers on the New York Sentinel Ladies' Page. Meanwhile, news headlines buzz about a shooting at J.P. Morgan's mansion and the sinkin

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

Murder Your Darlings

J.J. Murphy · 316 pages

When she stumbles over the dead body of drama critic Leland Mayflower and an aspiring writer named Billy Faulkner is accused of the murder, Dorothy Parker investigates with the aid of her fellow Algonquin Round Tablemates.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
❤️

The Orphanmaster

Jean Zimmerman · 433 pages

It is 1663 in the tiny, hardscrabble Dutch colony of New Amsterdam, now present-day southern Manhattan. Orphan children are going missing, and among those looking into the mysterious state of affairs are a quick-witted twenty-two-year-old trader, Blandine van Couvering, herself an orphan, and a dashing British spy named Edward Drummond. --From dust jacket.

Historical MysteryKids in DangerNew York CityHistorical Fiction
❤️

Seven for a Secret

Lyndsay Faye · 470 pages

Timothy and Valentine Wilde must once again delve into the darkest underbelly of old New York. When the beautiful and terrified Mrs Lucy Adams stumbles into the Tombs, headquarters of New York's newly formed police force, it's the beginning of a dense, thorny maze of crime for copper star Timothy Wilde. He's hardened to the injustices of life in the unforgiving city he's grown up in, but that does

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

The Raven in the Foregate

Ellis Peters · 246 pages

Christmas, 1141 AD. Abbot Radulfus returns from London, bringing with him a priest for the vacant living of Holy Cross (known as the Foregate), a man of presence, scholarship and discipline, but neither humility nor the common touch. When he is found drowned in the mill-pond, suspicion is cast in many directions, not least towards a young man who came in the priest's train, sent to work in Brother

Historical MysteryChristmasMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

The Blood-Dimmed Tide

Rennie Airth

With the publication of the New York Times Notable Book River of Darkness, Rennie Airth established himself as a master of suspense. The Blood- Dimmed Tide, set in 1932, marks the return of the beloved Inspector John Madden, whose discovery of a young girl's mutilated corpse near his home in rural England brings him out of retirement despite his wife's misgivings. Soon he finds himself chasing a k

Historical MysteryKids in DangerMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

A Deadly Affection

Cuyler Overholt · 454 pages

"One of the first women practicing in the advanced new field of psychology, Dr. Genevieve Summerford is used to forging her own path. But when one of her patients is arrested for murder--a murder Genevieve fears she may have unwittingly provoked--she is forced to seek help to solve the crime and clear her patient's name ... and her own"--

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

A Curtain Falls

Stefanie Pintoff · 403 pages

1906. When a chorus girl is found dead on a Broadway stage, dressed in the leading lady's costume, Mulvaney knows that news of a possible serial killer would be potentially disastrous to the burgeoning theater world.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

Deadly Election

Lindsey Davis · 360 pages

"In the first century A.D., during Domitian's reign, Flavia Albia is ready for a short break from her family. So, in July, she returns to Rome, leaving them at their place on the coast. Albia, the daughter of Marcus Didius Falco, now retired as private informer, has taken up her father's former profession and it's time to get back to work. The first order business, however, is the corpse found in

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionFirst Person Narrator
🙂

The Scent of Death

Andrew Taylor · 474 pages

Manhattan, 1778. A city of profiteers, loyalists and double agents. New York is home to a tide of refugees seeking justice from the British crown. Edward Savill is sent from London to investigate the claims of dispossessed loyalists. No sooner does he land than he becomes embroiled in a murder.

Historical MysteryNew York CityHistorical FictionMystery
🙂

No Good Deed

Nekesa Afia

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

Mistletoe and Murder

Carola Dunn · 258 pages

Historical MysteryChristmasMysterySeries
🙂

The Queen of Bedlam

Robert McCammon · 656 pages

Investigating New York City's first serial killer in 1702, magistrate's clerk Matthew Corbert contemplates working with an elderly asylum resident who may hold the key to the killer's identity, in a case that is further challenged by the murderer's dark designs for the city.

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

Winter at Death's Hotel

Kenneth M. Cameron

Historical MysteryNew York CityMysteryHistorical Fiction
🙂

Crocodile on the Sandbank

Elizabeth Peters · 280 pages

Thirty-one-year-old Victorian gentlewoman Amelia Peabody has not only inherited her father's fortune, but she is also blessed with his strong will as well. Now she's headed for Cairo, accompanied by a girl with a tarnished past, to indulge her passion for Egyptology. Little did she know that murder and a homicidal mummy lay in wait for her.

Historical MysteryMysteryHistorical FictionSeries
📖 New 2026 Kindles just released. See them on Amazon ↗