AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

The Outcast: a modern retelling of The Scarlet Letter

Jolina Petersheim · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

The River

Beverly Lewis · 392 pages

"Tilly and Ruth, two formerly Amish sisters, are plagued by unresolved relationships when they reluctantly return to Lancaster County for their parents' landmark wedding anniversary. Since departing their Plain upbringing, Tilly has married an Englisher, but Ruth remains single and hasn't entirely forgotten her failed courtship with her Amish beau. Past meets present as Tilly and Ruth yearn for ac

Christian FictionSistersFamily SecretsSmall Town
❤️

We Were the Mulvaneys

Joyce Carol Oates · 464 pages

Religious IdentitySistersSmall TownFamily Secrets
❤️

Plain Truth

Jodi Picoult · 416 pages

From the bestselling author of My Sister's Keeper comes the riveting story of a murder that shatters the picturesque calm of Amish country -- and tests the heart and soul of the lawyer defending the woman at the center of the storm. The discovery of a dead infant in an Amish barn shakes Lancaster County to its core. But the police investigation leads to a more shocking disclosure: circumstantia

Religious IdentitySmall TownFamily SecretsMultiple POV
❤️

Rejoice

Karen Kingsbury, Gary Smalley · 369 pages

Brooke Baxter has achieved everything this world has to offer--a prestigious career, a beautiful home, and two wonderful children. Her recent return to her faith is an encouragement to her family. But if she faces tremendous loss, can her fledgling faith and her rocky marriage survive?

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySistersFamily Secrets
❤️

The Gilly Salt Sisters

Tiffany Baker · 384 pages

Two sisters in Cape Cod fight over the town's wealthiest bachelor as they learn about life, love, and family history.

SistersFamily SecretsSmall TownMultiple POV
❤️

Let the Church Say Amen

ReShonda Tate Billingsley · 277 pages

Reverend Simon Jackson's dedication to the church that he has transformed into one of the most influential religious institutions in the South has left his family including his lonely wife Lorretta, rebellious daughter Rachel, troubled son David, and younger son Johnathan, who hides a secret that could destroy his father's beliefs, bereft and struggling. In her riveting second novel, ReShonda Tate

Christian FictionReligious IdentityFamily SecretsContemporary Fiction
❤️

His Love Endures Forever

Beth Wiseman · 326 pages

Danielle is anything but Amish. Just her luck to fall in love with an Amish guy. Now she's 18, pregnant, and hopeful that Matthew will do the right thing and marry her. When Matthew walks away from her and their unborn child, she has nowhere to turn. Her unlikely friendship with Levi offers some comfort-- yet they have so little in common. Does God have plans beyond what her mind can imagine, that

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySmall TownTeen Pregnancy
❤️

When the Soul Mends

Cindy Woodsmall

Returning to the home she fled in disgrace, will Hannah find healing for the wounds of the past?After receiving a desperate and confusing call from her sister, Hannah Lapp reluctantly returns to the Old Order Amish community of her Pennsylvania childhood. Having fled in disgrace more than two years earlier, she finally has settled into a satisfying role in the Englischer world. She also has found

Christian FictionSistersFamily SecretsSmall Town
❤️

A Psalm for Lost Girls

Katie Bayerl · 368 pages

"Determined to protect her sister Tess's memory, Callie da Costa sets out to prove Tess wasn't really a saint and finds herself pulled into a kidnapping investigation"--

SistersReligious IdentitySmall TownMultiple POV
❤️

Secrets of the Tulip Sisters

Susan Mallery · 463 pages

Kelly Murphy's life as a tulip farmer is pretty routine - up at dawn, off to work, lather, rinse, repeat. But everything changes one sun-washed summer with two dramatic homecomings: Griffith Burnett - Tulpen Crossing's prodigal son, who's set his sights on Kelly - and Olivia, her beautiful, wayward and, as far as Kelly is concerned, unwelcome sister. Tempted by Griffith, annoyed by Olivia, Kelly i

SistersFamily SecretsSmall TownMultiple POV
❤️

So Far from God

Ana Castillo · 251 pages

Tome is a small, outwardly sleepy hamlet in central New Mexico. In Ana Castillo's hands, though, it stands wondrously revealed as a place of marvels, teeming with life and with all manner of collisions: the past with the present, the real with the supernatural, the comic with the horrific, the Native American with the Hispano with the Anglo, the women with the men. With the talkative, intimate voi

Religious IdentitySistersSmall TownMultiple POV
❤️

These Things Hidden

Heather Gudenkauf · 376 pages

"When teenager Allison Glenn is sent to prison for a heinous crime, she leaves behind her reputation as Linden Falls' golden girl forever. Her parents deny the existence of their once-perfect child. Her former friends exult her downfall. Her sister, Brynn, faces whispered rumors every day in the hallways of their small Iowa high school. It's Brynn--shy, quiet Brynn--who carries the burden of what

SistersFamily SecretsSmall TownTeen Pregnancy
❤️

Three Daughters

Consuelo Saah Baehr · 712 pages

From the fertile hills of a tiny village near Jerusalem to the elegant townhouses of Georgetown, Three Daughters is a historical saga that chronicles the lives, loves, and secrets of three generations of Palestinian Christian women. Born in rural Palestine, just before the dawn of the twentieth century, Miriam adores her father and is certain his love will protect her, but she soon finds that trad

SistersReligious IdentityChristian FictionMultiple POV
❤️
SistersFamily SecretsSmall TownContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Bastard of Istanbul

Elif Shafak · 368 pages

SistersFamily SecretsTeen PregnancyMultiple POV
❤️

The Last Days of California: A Novel

Mary Miller · 233 pages

Fourteen-year-old Jess' beliefs falter when her evangelical father packs up the family, including her secretly pregnant older sister and her long-suffering mother, to travel across the country and save souls ahead of the anticipated end of the world.

SistersReligious IdentityTeen PregnancyContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Opposite of Hallelujah

Anna Jarzab · 452 pages

For eight of her sixteen years Carolina Mitchell's older sister Hannah has been a nun in a convent, almost completely out of touch with her family--so when she suddenly abandons her vocation and comes home, nobody knows quite how to handle the situation, or guesses what explosive secrets she is hiding.

SistersReligious IdentityFamily SecretsContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Silver Star

Jeannette Walls · 304 pages

Two motherless sisters--Bean and Liz--are shuttled to Virginia, where their Uncle Tinsley lives in the decaying mansion that's been in their family for generations. When school starts in the fall, Bean easily adjusts and makes friends, and Liz becomes increasingly withdrawn. Then something happens to Liz and Bean is left to challenge the injustice of the adult world.

SistersFamily SecretsSmall TownContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Amish Midwife

Mindy Starns Clark, Leslie Gould

Christian FictionReligious IdentityFamily SecretsContemporary Fiction
❤️

Gilead

Marilynne Robinson · 256 pages

**WINNER OF THE 2005 PULITZER PRIZE FOR FICTION** In 1956, toward the end of Reverend John Ames’s life, he begins a letter to his young son, an account of himself and his forebears. Ames is the son of an Iowan preacher and the grandson of a minister who, as a young man in Maine, saw a vision of Christ bound in chains and came west to Kansas to fight for abolition: He “preached men into the Civi

Christian FictionReligious IdentityFamily SecretsSmall Town
❤️

The Letters

Suzanne Woods Fisher

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySmall TownContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Undoing of Saint Silvanus

Beth Moore · 468 pages

Jillian Slater hadn't seen her father or his mother in almost 20 years until, on the news that her father had finally drunk himself to death, Adella Atwater, the manager of her grandmother's apartment house, calls and says Jillian's expenses would be paid if she'd fly in to New Orleans for the burial. What Adella didn't tell her was that the apartment house bears the dead weight of a long and pain

Christian FictionReligious IdentityFamily SecretsContemporary Fiction
❤️

The House on Willow Street

Cathy Kelly · 510 pages

"Tess used to be happy with her lot: she lives in the idyllic Irish coastal village, Avalon, with her teenage son, Zach and nine-year-old Kitty, and works in the local antiques shop. Her only regret in life is that everything went so horribly wrong with her first love. Then her marriage falls apart and her first love returns to Avalon. Suki, Tess's sister, fled Ireland years ago to marry politicia

SistersFamily SecretsSmall TownContemporary Fiction
❤️

Amish Promises

Leslie Gould · 511 pages

"When an English and an Amish family become neighbors in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, their lives are linked in unexpected ways through conflict, then friendship, and finally, love"--

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySmall TownMultiple POV

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.