AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Two Brides Too Many

Mona Hodgson · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Waterfall

Lisa Tawn Bergren · 384 pages

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

A Passion Most Pure

Julie Lessman · 480 pages

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Heiress

Susan May Warren

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

With You Always

Jody Hedlund · 368 pages

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Irish Meadows

Susan Anne Mason · 455 pages

"At the renowned Irish Meadows horse farm in New York, 1911, sisters Brianna and Colleen O'Leary struggle to reconcile their own dreams with their father's plans for the farm and his demanding marriage expectations"--

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Faith

Lori Copeland · 291 pages

Prolific author Copeland kicks off another historical Western series with this pleasing tale of mail-order brides set in 1872. When their pastor father dies suddenly, leaving little money, three sisters realize that they need to take drastic action to survive. Each answers a newspaper ad soliciting Christian brides. Faith goes to Texas, where her intended, a well-to-do rancher named Nicholas S

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

A Promise for Ellie

Lauraine Snelling · 320 pages

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Bride Bargain

Kelly Eileen Hake · 317 pages

When dropped from the wagon train along the Platte River for not pulling their load, Clara Fields is determined to find a way to provide for her newly-widowed aunt. So she strikes a bargain with an aging storekeeper that in exchange for finding a bride for his son Clara can have his house to run a boardinghouse. But Dr. Saul Reed is not interested in getting tied down to Buttonwood in the middle o

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Distant Dreams

Judith Pella, Tracie Peterson · 382 pages

Only her father understood her love of the unknown and the promise of distant dreams. Caught up in the excitement of America's westward expansion in 1835, fifteen-year-old Carolina Adams falls in love with the railroad. Living in a society that decidedly looks down on such aspirations in a woman, Carolina longs to study more masculine subjects such as science and advanced mathematics. Fresh out of

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

McKenzie

Penny Zeller · 314 pages

"McKenzie Worthington heads west as a mail-order bride with plans to return to Boston as soon as she finds and rescues her sister, Kaydie, from an abusive marriage. What she didn't count on was falling in love with her husband, a handsome, godly rancher named Zach Sawyer"--Provided by publisher.

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Tried and True

Mary Connealy · 317 pages

"In 1860s Idaho Territory, Kylie Wilde is disguised as a man, homesteading for profit so she can live comfortably back East. But love or danger could change her mind"--

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

When Love Calls

Lorna Seilstad · 341 pages

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Summer of Promise

Amanda Cabot · 410 pages

The last place Abigail wants to spend the summer of 1885 is Fort Laramie in the Wyoming Territory, but can a handsome lieutenant change her mind?

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Red Siren

M.L. Tyndall · 318 pages

When Captain Dajon Waite is asked to take guardianship of Faith Westcott--lady by day and pirate along the Carolina coast by night--and her sisters, will he be able to save Faith and his own reputation from the schemes of rival Sir Wilhelm Carteret?

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Written on the Wind

Judith Pella · 461 pages

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

A Daughter's Inheritance

Tracie Peterson, Judith McCoy Miller · 383 pages

Seventeen-year-old Fanny has never put much stock in the conventions of society. In fact, she has given her heart to Michael, the family boat-keeper. But when she receives a surprising inheritance, she discovers just how oppressive society can be . . . and that she may be trusting the wrong people. Dare she follow her heart and risk going against her family? What if she loses everything she's e

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Angel Sister

Ann H. Gabhart

Christian FictionSistersHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Hide in Plain Sight

Marta Perry · 256 pages

SistersChristian FictionSeries StarterSeries
❤️

A Promise to Believe In

Tracie Peterson

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries
❤️

The Covenant

Beverly Lewis · 318 pages

Secrets threaten the serenity of their cloistered world. Following such bestsellers as The Shunning and The Postcard, Beverly Lewis's explosive new novel, The Covenant, unveils the layers of deeply rooted Amish tradition as seen through the eyes of Leah and Sadie Ebersol, two courting-age sisters. At the close of World War II, the heart and soul of Gobbler's Knob offers everything young Leah Ebers

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Whence Came a Prince

Liz Curtis Higgs · 551 pages

SistersChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries
❤️

Stuck in the Middle

Virginia Smith · 336 pages

Christian FictionSistersSeries StarterRomance
❤️

True to You

Becky Wade · 600 pages

Christian FictionSistersSeries StarterSeries
🙂

Beyond All Measure

Dorothy Love · 320 pages

Christian FictionHistorical FictionSeries StarterSeries
📖 New 2026 Kindles just released. See them on Amazon ↗