AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Third Time's a Charm

Virginia Smith · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Paige Rewritten

Erynn Mangum · 299 pages

Paige is still overcommitted but making more time for God when Preslee, the sister she has not spoken with in almost a year, returns wearing an engagement ring, the youth pastor asks her to take a job at the church, and an old boyfriend resurfaces.

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Tried and True

Mary Connealy · 317 pages

"In 1860s Idaho Territory, Kylie Wilde is disguised as a man, homesteading for profit so she can live comfortably back East. But love or danger could change her mind"--

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

With You Always

Jody Hedlund · 368 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Baroness

Susan May Warren

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

The Judgment

Beverly Lewis · 325 pages

Rose Kauffman is engaged to Silas Good, a well-liked Amish fellow, so why does she still pine for Nick Franco, the former foster son of the bishop? Especially now that Nick has left the Amish community under a cloud of suspicion after the death of the bishop's biological son. Meanwhile, Rose's older sister, Hen, has returned to live at her parents' farm with her young daughter. Hen and her modern

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Hide in Plain Sight

Marta Perry · 256 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

True to You

Becky Wade · 600 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

The Witness

Dee Henderson · 378 pages

Police Chief Luke Granger's witness to a murder, Amy Griffin, has been on the run for years. Her family thinks she was murdered eight years ago, but Amy chose to accept a life in the shadows in order to protect her sisters' lives. Now unveiled secrets about their father have thrust the sisters into the public spotlight. The man who wants Amy dead now sees her sisters as the way to locate her. Luke

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

When the Soul Mends

Cindy Woodsmall

Returning to the home she fled in disgrace, will Hannah find healing for the wounds of the past?After receiving a desperate and confusing call from her sister, Hannah Lapp reluctantly returns to the Old Order Amish community of her Pennsylvania childhood. Having fled in disgrace more than two years earlier, she finally has settled into a satisfying role in the Englischer world. She also has found

Christian FictionSistersRomanceFemale Lead
❤️

A Promise for Ellie

Lauraine Snelling · 320 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

A Sister's Hope

Wanda E. Brunstetter · 297 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Whence Came a Prince

Liz Curtis Higgs · 551 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

While Love Stirs

Lorna Seilstad · 341 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Distant Dreams

Judith Pella, Tracie Peterson · 382 pages

Only her father understood her love of the unknown and the promise of distant dreams. Caught up in the excitement of America's westward expansion in 1835, fifteen-year-old Carolina Adams falls in love with the railroad. Living in a society that decidedly looks down on such aspirations in a woman, Carolina longs to study more masculine subjects such as science and advanced mathematics. Fresh out of

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Two Brides Too Many

Mona Hodgson · 353 pages

Kat and Nell Sinclair are headed west--away from the manicured lawns of Maine to the boisterous, booming mining town of Cripple Creek, Colorado to start new lives for themselves as mail-order brides.Aboard the train, romantic dreamer Nell carries a photo of her intended close to her heart and imagines an exciting and love-filled future, while her pragmatic older sister Kat resigns herself to marri

Christian FictionSistersRomanceFemale Lead
❤️

Waterfall

Lisa Tawn Bergren · 384 pages

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Love Finds You in Sisters, Oregon

Melody Carlson · 311 pages

Hope Bartolli has avoided Sisters for years both her hometown of Sisters, Oregon and her two sisters who live there. But when the 32 year old corporate lawyer returns home to attend her beloved grandmothers funeral, shes surprised to learn that she has inherited Nana's old house, her little dog Andy and an unexpected friendship with Nana's attorney, Lewis. If she had any hopes of burying the hatch

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

The Bride Bargain

Kelly Eileen Hake · 317 pages

When dropped from the wagon train along the Platte River for not pulling their load, Clara Fields is determined to find a way to provide for her newly-widowed aunt. So she strikes a bargain with an aging storekeeper that in exchange for finding a bride for his son Clara can have his house to run a boardinghouse. But Dr. Saul Reed is not interested in getting tied down to Buttonwood in the middle o

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Faith

Lori Copeland · 291 pages

Prolific author Copeland kicks off another historical Western series with this pleasing tale of mail-order brides set in 1872. When their pastor father dies suddenly, leaving little money, three sisters realize that they need to take drastic action to survive. Each answers a newspaper ad soliciting Christian brides. Faith goes to Texas, where her intended, a well-to-do rancher named Nicholas S

Christian FictionSistersRomanceFunny
❤️

A Promise to Believe In

Tracie Peterson

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Irish Meadows

Susan Anne Mason · 455 pages

"At the renowned Irish Meadows horse farm in New York, 1911, sisters Brianna and Colleen O'Leary struggle to reconcile their own dreams with their father's plans for the farm and his demanding marriage expectations"--

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

A Passion Redeemed

Julie Lessman

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

Summer of Promise

Amanda Cabot · 410 pages

The last place Abigail wants to spend the summer of 1885 is Fort Laramie in the Wyoming Territory, but can a handsome lieutenant change her mind?

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance
❤️

The Calling

Suzanne Woods Fisher · 332 pages

Struggling with her faith during a summer shared with five older Amish sisters, Bethany volunteers at a local soup kitchen while railing at the handsome but annoying Jimmy before uncovering a heartbreaking secret.

Christian FictionSistersFemale LeadRomance

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.