AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Mail Order Millie

Katie Crabapple · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

No One's Bride

Nerys Leigh · 300 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Doctor in Petticoats

Mary Connealy

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

The Lady and the Mountain Man

Misty M. Beller · 294 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

The Peacemaker

Lori Copeland · 298 pages

Bull-headed Wynne Elliot has one goal in mind: to track down Cass Claxton and shoot him dead for leaving her at the altar and running off with her money. But when Cass's brother Cole shows up, Wynne finds herself on an unexpected adventure, and she just might lose her heart. Beloved author Lori Copeland takes readers back in time to an era when cowboys were heroes and the rules of the Wild West pr

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

The Sheriff's Surrender

Susan Page Davis · 319 pages

In 1885 in Fergus, Idaho, Gert Dooley has an unusual job for a woman--test firing guns for her brother the gunsmith--and years of practice have made her an excellent shot. When a murder in town scares her friends, Gert starts the Ladies' Shooting Club to teach the women how to shoot. Their independence upsets the men in town, and Sheriff Chapman finds himself trying to solve a murder and restore p

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

A Lady in Defiance

Heather Blanton · 282 pages

RomanceHistorical FictionChristian FictionCowboys
❤️

The Trouble with Patience

Maggie Brendan · 381 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

The Anonymous Bride

Vickie McDonough · 359 pages

"It's been years, but Luke Davis is back--older and wiser--and still alone. Returning as Lookout's new town marshal, Luke is determined to face the past and move on. But when he discovers that the woman who betrayed him is now a widow, all his plans fall at his feet. Rachel has carried her guilty shame for eleven years. Her marriage to James Hamilton was not what Luke or the town thought it to be.

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

A Texan's Promise

Shelley Gray

RomanceHistorical FictionCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Every Little Thing About You

Lori Wick · 364 pages

The first meeting between Slater Rawlings and Liberty Drake could hardly be called ideal. As acting deputy of Shotgun, Texas, Liberty is simply enforcing town laws. But Slater, a former Texas Ranger with a restless spirit, is surprised to find himself on the wrong side of the law-and even more shocked that it's a *she* that's arresting him! Yet despite his rocky start in Shotgun, Slater finds

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

McKenzie

Penny Zeller · 314 pages

"McKenzie Worthington heads west as a mail-order bride with plans to return to Boston as soon as she finds and rescues her sister, Kaydie, from an abusive marriage. What she didn't count on was falling in love with her husband, a handsome, godly rancher named Zach Sawyer"--Provided by publisher.

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

From a Distance

Tamera Alexander · 352 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

A Suitor for Jenny

Margaret Brownley · 315 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Daughter of Joy

Kathleen Morgan · 406 pages

RomanceHistorical FictionCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Mail Order Bride: Katie

Vivi Holt · 178 pages

Historical FictionRomanceChristian FictionCowboys
❤️

Fair Play

Deeanne Gist · 464 pages

"In this historical romance, a lady doctor and a Texas Ranger meet at the 1893 Chicago World's Fair. Despite their difference of opinion on the role of women, they fight for the underprivileged children in the Nineteenth Ward"--

RomanceHistorical FictionCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Paper Roses

Amanda Cabot

RomanceHistorical FictionCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

High Desert Haven

Lynnette Bonner · 322 pages

"When her husband dies in a mysterious riding accident, Nicki Trent is left with a toddler and a rundown ranch. Determined to bring her ranch back from the brink of death, Nicki hires handsome Jason Jordan to help. But when William, her neighbor, starts pressing for her hand in marriage, the bank calls in a loan she didn't even know about, bullets start flying, and a burlap dummy with a knife in i

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

A Worthy Pursuit

Karen Witemeyer · 417 pages

In 1891 Texas, teacher Charlotte Atherton is on the run to keep a little girl entrusted to her care safe, while tracker Stone Hammond is in close pursuit--until he learns the truth of the situation and discovers his heart may have a new pursuit.

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

A Match Made in Texas

Karen Witemeyer, Mary Connealy, Regina Jennings, Carol Cox · 379 pages

"A matchmaker on the Texas frontier gives three couples a little nudge toward love--until the tables are turned on her in this volume of four novellas"--

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Love in the Balance

Regina Jennings · 429 pages

Molly Lovelace dreams of being a society leader in 1879 Lockhart, Texas, but being smitten with handsome wrangler Bailey Garner doesn’t seem the quickest route. If only he would settle down so he could support a family. Bailey imagines doing great things for God, but his greatest obstacle is Molly. As long as he thought they’d be married, he excused their stolen kisses, but when she keeps refus

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Chasing The Sun

Tracie Peterson

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Hearts Stolen

Caryl McAdoo · 364 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction
❤️

Forevermore

Cathy Marie Hake · 351 pages

Historical FictionRomanceCowboysChristian Fiction

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.