AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

All the Little Liars

Charlaine Harris · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Pouncing on Murder

Laurie Cass · 344 pages

Springtime in Chilson, Michigan, means it's librarian Minnie Hamilton's favorite time of year: maple syrup season! But her excitement fades when her favorite syrup provider, Henry Gill, dies in a sugaring accident. It's tough news to swallow...even if the old man wasn't as sweet as his product. On the bookmobile rounds with her trusty rescue cat Eddie, Minnie meets Adam, the old man's friend, w

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

On Borrowed Time

Jenn McKinlay · 294 pages

When her brother, Jack, a world-traveling consultant for a coffee company, goes missing, Briar Creek library director Lindsey Norris gets mixed up in a strange case involving South American business dealings and an exotic woman.

LibrariansMissing PersonCozy MysterySmall Town
❤️
LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

Night Sins

Tami Hoag · 550 pages

Deer Lake is a small Minnesota town where people know their neighbours and crime is something that happens on the evening news. But the illusion of safety is shattered when eight-year-old Josh Kirkwood disappears. All the police find is his duffel bag with a note stuffed inside, 'Ignorance is not innocence but SIN'. With each passing hour the search for Josh takes on a more ominous intensity. For

Kids in DangerMissing PersonSmall TownMystery
❤️

Witch Way to Murder

Shirley Damsgaard · 292 pages

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

Booked for Trouble

Eva Gates · 304 pages

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownFirst Person Narrator
❤️

Dangerous Alterations

Elizabeth Lynn Casey · 264 pages

When her philandering ex, along with his great-aunt, is murdered, Yankee librarian Tori Sinclair must rely on her friends from the Sweet Briar Ladies Society sewing circle to help her prove her innocence before everything she has worked so hard for unravels.

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

Wolfhunter River

Rachel Caine · 330 pages

Kids in DangerSmall TownMissing PersonFirst Person Narrator
❤️

May Day

Jess Lourey · 226 pages

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

Cockatiels at Seven

Donna Andrews · 320 pages

When her old friend Karen drops by with two-year-old son Timmy, Meg Langslow reluctantly agrees to babysit just for a little while. But when nightfall comes, the toddler is still in residence and Karen isn't answering any phone calls. Meg decides she must find out what's happening, so the next morning, with Timmy in tow, she retraces her friend's footsteps--and begins to suspect that Karen's disap

Missing PersonCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

How to Solve Your Own Murder

Kristen Perrin · 358 pages

Cozy MysteryMissing PersonSmall TownMystery
❤️

The Advocate

Teresa Burrell · 233 pages

Kids in DangerMissing PersonTense and SuspensefulMystery
❤️

Murder Past Due

Miranda James · 345 pages

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

We Are All Guilty Here

Karin Slaughter · 439 pages

Missing PersonKids in DangerSmall TownTense and Suspenseful
❤️

All Good People Here

Ashley Flowers · 336 pages

You can’t ever know for sure what happens behind closed doors. Everyone from Wakarusa, Indiana, remembers the infamous case of January Jacobs, who was discovered in a ditch hours after her family awoke to find her gone. Margot Davies was six at the time, the same age as January—and they were next-door neighbors. In the twenty years since, Margot has grown up, moved away, and become a big-city j

Missing PersonKids in DangerSmall TownMystery
❤️

Thirty-Four and a Half Predicaments

Denise Grover Swank · 372 pages

Missing PersonCozy MysterySmall TownFirst Person Narrator
❤️

Murder by the Book

Betsy Brannon Green · 275 pages

Murder becomes the name of the game when small-town librarian Kennedy Killingsworth meets Foster Scoggins, the leathery-faced resident who applied for a library card just hours before his gruesome death. To complicate matters, Kennedy's ex-husband, Deputy Cade Burrell, seems desperate to find any reason to talk to Kennedy ever since his scandalous affair.

LibrariansCozy MysterySmall TownMystery
❤️

The Return of Ellie Black

Emiko Jean · 299 pages

Missing PersonKids in DangerSmall TownMystery
❤️

The Bad Book Affair

Ian Sansom · 358 pages

Hapless mobile librarian Israel Armstrong is investigating the disappearance of local politician's daughter who went missing after borrowing two classics from the special unshelved category.

LibrariansMissing PersonCozy MysteryMystery
❤️

Gone Missing

Linda Castillo · 277 pages

Investigating the disappearance of an Amish teenager, chief of police Kate Burkholder and state agent John Tomasetti stumble on a dead body at the same time another girl goes missing, and later discover sinister links to numerous cold cases.

Missing PersonSmall TownMysteryTense and Suspenseful
❤️

The Naturals

Jennifer Lynn Barnes · 308 pages

Young Adult thriller book series by Jennifer Lynn Barnes about a classified FBI program that recruits teenagers with exceptional abilities to solve cold cases. The protagonist, Cassie Hobbes, joins other gifted teens, including a profiler and a statistician, in this program. The series combines suspenseful crime-solving with personal danger as the Naturals find themselves in a lethal game of cat a

Kids in DangerMissing PersonMysteryFirst Person Narrator
🙂

Raising Innocence

Shannon Mayer · 288 pages

Kids in DangerMissing PersonTense and SuspensefulFirst Person Narrator
🙂

By a Spider's Thread

Laura Lippman · 368 pages

The winner of every major literary award in crime fiction, Laura Lippman brings back her complex and vulnerably human Baltimore P.I., Tess Monaghan, in a tense, expertly spun tale of a family torn asunder by forces it can barely comprehend.Mark Rubin's family is missing -- and the police can't do a thing because all the evidence indicates that his wife left willingly. So the successful furrier tur

Missing PersonKids in DangerMysteryTense and Suspenseful
🙂

Fatal Fixer-Upper

Jennie Bentley, Jenna Bennett · 332 pages

With the help of a hunky handyman, Avery Baker, a former New York textile designer, begins fixing up her aunt's crumbling estate, until she discovers clues that lead to a missing local professor, in this first installment in a new mystery series that features home-renovation and design tips.

Cozy MysteryMissing PersonSmall TownMystery

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.