AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

Between Sinners and Saints

Marie Sexton · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

Autoboyography

Christina Lauren · 416 pages

Three years ago, Tanner Scott’s family relocated from California to Utah, a move that nudged the bisexual teen temporarily back into the closet. Now, with one semester of high school to go, and no obstacles between him and out-of-state college freedom, Tanner plans to coast through his remaining classes and clear out of Utah. But when his best friend Autumn dares him to take Provo High’s presti

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

Brothers of the Wild North Sea

Harper Fox · 396 pages

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentityRomance
❤️

Diving in Deep

K.A. Mitchell · 201 pages

"Cameron Lewis loves his job as an instructor/trainer for a water safety firm that inspects water parks. He gets to travel from March through September, always moving on to something different. When a strange emptiness starts plaguing him, he chalks it up to turning thirty. He manages to shake off the feeling-until he walks into a classroom and discovers that the eye candy in the front row is actu

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistSpicyContemporary Fiction
❤️

Release

Patrick Ness

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

Role Model

Rachel Reid · 353 pages

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistSpicyContemporary Fiction
❤️

Heated Rivalry: Now Streaming on Crave and HBO Max (First Time Trade)

Rachel Reid · 373 pages

Pro hockey star Shane Hollander isn’t just crazy talented, he’s got a spotless reputation. Hockey is his life. Now that he’s captain of the Montreal Voyageurs, he won’t let anything jeopardize that, especially the sexy Russian whose hard body keeps him awake at night. Boston Bears captain Ilya Rozanov is everything Shane’s not. The self-proclaimed king of the ice, he’s as cocky as he is talente

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistSpicyMale Lead
❤️

The Fall

Tal Bauer · 810 pages

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentitySpicy
❤️

Wide Awake

David Levithan · 221 pages

In the not-too-impossible-to-imagine future, a gay Jewish man has been elected president of the United States. Until the governor of one state decides that some election results in his state are invalid, awarding crucial votes to the other candidate, and his fellow party member. Thus is the inspiration for couple Jimmy and Duncan to lend their support to their candidate by deciding to take part in

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

Her Name in the Sky

Kelly Quindlen

Hannah has big plans for senior year: football games, Mardi Gras parties, and spring break on the beach with her tight-knit group of friends. No drama, no detours. Just a year to remember. Falling for another girl—her best friend, Baker—was not part of the plan. Hannah knows she should date Wally, the earnest, dependable boy her sister is always teasing her about. She should be happy when Cl

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Weight of It All

N.R. Walker · 254 pages

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationContemporary FictionRomance
❤️

A Forbidden Rumspringa

Keira Andrews · 224 pages

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationReligious IdentityRomance
❤️

Teacher of the Year

M.A. Wardell · 347 pages

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationContemporary FictionRomance
❤️

American Prince

Sierra Simone · 320 pages

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationContemporary FictionMale Lead
❤️

A Raging Fire

Adam Carpenter

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationContemporary FictionRomance
❤️

Honesty

Seth King · 301 pages

As a closeted teenager in the Deep South with a holy-roller father and the scars to prove it, bookworm Cole Furman has resigned himself to experiencing life and love only within the pages of his favorite novels. But after Nick Flores seems to walk off a page and starts to rewrite his story, Cole finds his dreams spinning into a dazzling - and complicated - reality.

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

The God Box

Alex Sanchez · 260 pages

When openly gay Manuel transfers to Paul's high school, Paul, a born-again Christian, begins to question his own sexuality.

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

The Screwed Up Life of Charlie the Second

Drew Ferguson · 263 pages

A gay Lutheran teen, Charles James Stewart II, chronicles a very memorable senior year at South High in Crystal Lake, Ill.

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

Any Way The Wind Blows

E. Lynn Harris · 368 pages

When her wedding to John "Basil" Henderson didn't come off as planned, Yancey Harrington Braxton flew off to L.A. and remade herself as mega-diva Yancey B. And Basil started concentrating on his career as a high-powered sports agent. But then Yancey's first single, "Any Way the Wind Blows," hit the charts, and now it threatens to blow Basil's cover--if anyone learns who it's really about. And i

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistContemporary FictionSpicy
❤️

Texas Pride

Kindle Alexander

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationContemporary FictionRomance
❤️

South of Sunshine

Dana Elmendorf · 254 pages

Kaycee Jean McCoy hides the fact that she's gay from her small southern town of Sunshine, Tennessee. But when Bren Dawson moves to town, she's forced to decide between love or giving in to the social prejudice of her town.

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationReligious IdentityContemporary Fiction
❤️

Trust

Ella Frank · 348 pages

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistSpicyRomance
❤️

Kage Unleashed

Maris Black · 274 pages

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistSpicyRomance
❤️

Steamroller

Mary Calmes

Sexual OrientationLGBTQ+ ProtagonistSpicyRomance
❤️

The Nothingness of Ben

Brad Boney · 248 pages

LGBTQ+ ProtagonistSexual OrientationContemporary FictionMale Lead

In the works

To be read SpinnerCan’t pick your next book? Spin your Want to read.Blind date with a bookPick a mood, unwrap a surprise.Add a tiny librarySnap a little free library and its books.