AmongReaders.com Add a tiny library
📚 AmongReaders — track what you read, talk chapter by chapter without spoilers, and read with friends. Free.Join AmongReadersSign in

🧲 Books like this

The Puritans

Jack Cavanaugh · back to the book

What’s in it

Tap a tag: ❤ = this matters to me · tap again ✕ = don’t care · again to reset. The list below updates each time.

24 books with the same feel

Include books by the same author
❤️

First Light

Bodie Thoene, Brock Thoene · 395 pages

From Tyndale.com: Go back in time to first-century Jerusalem. It's a dark time in the world's holiest and most turbulent city. Walk with Peniel, the blind beggar who longs for rescue from his suffering. Peek into the lives of Susannah and Manaen, two lovers separated by overwhelming odds. And meet an unusual healer, who ignites a spark of controversy in the fire of hatred, deceit, and betrayal th

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Tennis Shoes Among the Nephites

Chris Heimerdinger · 228 pages

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySeries StarterHistorical Fiction
❤️

One Tuesday Morning / Beyond Tuesday Morning

Karen Kingsbury · 624 pages

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHidden IdentitySeries Starter
❤️

The Honorable Imposter: 1620

Gilbert Morris · 331 pages

Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Well

Stephanie Landsem · 306 pages

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySeries StarterHistorical Fiction
❤️

Rumors of War

Dean Hughes · 500 pages

Religious IdentityChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

A.D. 30

Ted Dekker · 432 pages

"A sweeping epic set in the harsh deserts of Arabia and ancient Palestine. A war that rages between kingdoms on the earth and in the heart. The harrowing journey of the woman at the center of it all. Step back in time to the year of our Lord...A.D. 30. The outcast daughter of one of the most powerful Bedouin sheikhs in Arabia, Maviah is called on to protect the very people who rejected her. When t

Religious IdentityChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Soon: The Beginning of the End

Jerry B. Jenkins · 360 pages

Paul Stepola, an agent working for the National Peacekeeping Organization (NPO), has been assigned to enforce compliance with the world government's prohibition on religion. Paul relishes his job and is good at it. He is determined to expose underground religion—flush it out, expose it, and kill it—until his life is turned upside down and he is forced to look at life in a different way. As Paul

Christian FictionReligious IdentitySeries StarterSeries
❤️

The Sister Wife

Diane Noble

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Somewhere to Belong

Judith McCoy Miller · 567 pages

Although she's always longed to see the outside world, Johanna Ilg believes her future is rooted in the Amana community inhabited by devout Christians. But when she learns a troubling secret, the world she thought she knew is shattered and she is forced to make difficult choices about a new life and the man she left behind. Berta Schumacher has lived a privileged life in Chicago, and when her pare

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Covenant

Beverly Lewis · 318 pages

Secrets threaten the serenity of their cloistered world. Following such bestsellers as The Shunning and The Postcard, Beverly Lewis's explosive new novel, The Covenant, unveils the layers of deeply rooted Amish tradition as seen through the eyes of Leah and Sadie Ebersol, two courting-age sisters. At the close of World War II, the heart and soul of Gobbler's Knob offers everything young Leah Ebers

Religious IdentityChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Pillar of Light

Gerald N. Lund

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

On This Foundation

Lynn Austin · 480 pages

Stone by Stone, the Wall Will Rise Once More Around God's City When news reaches him that Jerusalem's wall is shattered and its gates burned with fire, a distraught Nehemiah seeks God's guidance in fasting and prayer. Granted an unexpected leave from his duty as cupbearer to the Persian king Artaxerxes, Nehemiah sets out for Jerusalem to rebuild the city wall--never anticipating all the dangers

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
❤️
Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Measure of Katie Calloway

Serena B. Miller · 316 pages

The Civil War has ended, but in Katie Calloway's Georgia home conflict still rages. To protect herself and her young brother from her violent and unstable husband, she flees north, finding anonymity and sanctuary as the cook in a Northwoods lumber camp. The camp owner, Robert Foster, wonders if the lovely woman he's hired has the grit to survive the never-ending work and harsh conditions of a remo

Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Red Siren

M.L. Tyndall · 318 pages

When Captain Dajon Waite is asked to take guardianship of Faith Westcott--lady by day and pirate along the Carolina coast by night--and her sisters, will he be able to save Faith and his own reputation from the schemes of rival Sir Wilhelm Carteret?

Christian FictionHidden IdentitySeries StarterHistorical Fiction
❤️

A Name Unknown

Roseanna M. White · 428 pages

1914. Rosemary Gresham has no family beyond the band of former urchins that helped her survive as a girl in the mean streets of London. Grown now, they concentrate on stealing high-value items and have learned how to blend into upper-class society. But when Rosemary must determine whether a certain wealthy gentleman is loyal to Britain or to Germany, she is in for the challenge of a lifetime. How

Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Tried and True

Mary Connealy · 317 pages

"In 1860s Idaho Territory, Kylie Wilde is disguised as a man, homesteading for profit so she can live comfortably back East. But love or danger could change her mind"--

Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Damascus Way

Davis Bunn, Janette Oke

Christian FictionReligious IdentityHistorical FictionSeries
❤️

Kingdom's Dawn

Chuck Black · 160 pages

Religious IdentityChristian FictionSeries StarterSeries
❤️
Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Outsider

Ann H. Gabhart · 352 pages

Gabrielle Hope has a special gift of "knowing" the future. When she and her mother join the Pleasant Hill Shaker community in 1807, the members embrace her ability, although it sometimes frightens quiet Gabrielle. But when one vision comes true, a chain of events and an unlikely love challenge her loyalty to this chaste community.

Religious IdentityChristian FictionHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

Letter Perfect

Cathy Marie Hake · 448 pages

Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
❤️

The Unveiling

Tamara Leigh · 306 pages

Christian FictionHidden IdentityHistorical FictionSeries Starter
📖 New 2026 Kindles just released. See them on Amazon ↗